Normally I abhor dissection of posts with counter posts point by point but the last post was so full of glaring omissions...
Willmark: Yes I understand you also and your point of view. But that is how eBay works and is real even if intangible. But tell me, if you get offered or you find on eBay an auction of 300 Marauder CD in original blisters listed as Sweet Pony (totally wrong name just an example) and is going for $2.00, are you going to try to get it for $10.00 hoping no one will see you. Then get what you need and resale the rest at regular price making a big profit like 500% OR are you going to list the auction on this site? Essex and Wcrazy are looking to buy stuff cheap and make 300% out of it. Yes pisses a lot of people off but nothing wrong with it IMHO)
Actually your premise of minis mislabeled actually falls flat. That is precisely what I would do. If I bought by some miracle 300 minis as you described then I would offer them here first after I was done with what I want. Then after that put them back on eBay.
Also you talk about INFLATION? with collectors items this can not be done and is truly unrealistic. Instead of toy soldiers look at a Lamborghini or Viper (US version

....) from 1973 sold at $8000 then and tell the owner that with inflation now is worth $16000 and lets see what happens. When we all know that with collectors items this is not true. If I want to sell my Unreleased CD cannon as an example that was worth 15GBP at MO UK when produced 20+ years ago you will then offer me 25 or 30GBP? When we all know that the real value is about $300/$600.00 for it. Inflation can be used only for items widely available and very common to find. Rarity/Demand/Availability are the key words and there is no formula for it.
Actually inflation gauges and indexes are immensely useful tools to gauge the relative purchasing power of a given currency at a given time. Not the sole arbiter thou... see below.
You seem to be getting hung up on the notion that inflation index is the sole arbiter of price (which I never implied), merely it’s a baseline starting point.
You analogy with cars is flawed from the start. You are talking about a car (lamborghini) that has 5-10 made a year. That’s is scarcity; that is rare. Its not the greates of examples wither since they are built to order. Chaos Dwarf models are not that rare, that’s the problem. If you used eBay as ones sole source of information it might seem otherwise. But millions of models were produced. Again collector’s items? Perhaps. Rare? If you only look at eBay they are.
Simply put exotic cars=rare, unreleased chaos cannons=rare, widely sold and distributed 4th/5th edition CD minis, not so much.
If I want to sell my Unreleased CD cannon as an example that was worth 15GBP at MO UK when produced 20+ years ago you will then offer me 25 or 30GBP? When we all know that the real value is about $300/$600.00 for it. Inflation can be used only for items widely available and very common to find. Rarity/Demand/Availability are the key words and there is no formula for it.
Again, bad analogy. Your unreleased chaos cannon is something that truly is rare. Thus could conceivably justify high prices due to said rarity.
As for illegal well not illegal I expressed my self wrong, I don't care of what you are doing to them. If you guys post auctions here is just fine and very nice for the other. But what it bothers me are words like don't let Essex get it or similar. Is not nice, and what if they read this post? Also looking at the way I value stuff I might become your next victim O____o if I decide I want to get 4 full units of 3rd Ed CD's and rate them at 10GBP each. Or you are hurting a serious collector like Biklinko that is just trying to complete his collection like you guys are doing.
So if by using your logic that you see nothing wrong with what warhammer crazy is doing, I see nothing wrong with taking whatever means to stop them from getting minis at dirt-cheap prices. For reference, we didn’t start this whole mess. The debate is an exercise in futility as none of us here who actually want to use CD minis are going to see it otherwise quite frankly.
Essexgirl deserves everything that comes her way IMHO. No matter what “mental gymnastics” you use you are NEVER going to convince those who have been burnt by her, or her outrageous “pricing” otherwise.
I’m not concerned about biklinko or his collection. Means nothing to me other then if I really want something on “vultureBay” I have to take the fact that he has driven up prices in his bidding patterns and adjust mine accordingly
Sorry to tell you but GW really doesn't care about it believe me

for them doing so is unproductive. Manufacturing on demand was available from GW up to 7 years ago. You sent the code and they casted it. Looking at how GW is going in the future they will make available only time by time some selected models from the Archive. And believe me by 2008 all CD no matter what series will be OOP and will get harder to get.
As far as GW mail order goes. Wow. You work for them? You know their intention. Their latest statement regarding said matter was either a) a figment of our collective imaginations or b) some bad beer we were all drinking last night with the Easter Bunny. In other words unless you work for GW either possibility is possible, but with neither being plausible.
GW is a company, Companies make money. When a company’s sales keep delicling they ask why. After asking why they make changes to address said decrease in sales. If the cost is low enough to create models on demand I will not put it past GW to bring it back regardless of circumstances.
This is all just a waste of time anyways should GW release new CD minis for a new CD army..
Again, I understand your point, even if I disagree with them. Simply put however: Your logic is flawed from the start.